What is a credit memo in commercial lending?
In lending, a credit memo (short for credit memorandum, or credit approval memo) is the written analysis a bank prepares to recommend and approve a loan. It sets out who the borrower is, what they want, how they will repay, what protects the bank if they cannot, and why the loan fits the bank's credit policy.
Updated on
What a credit memo is, and what it is not
A credit memo is the bank's record of its lending decision. An analyst or underwriter writes it, a loan officer or committee with lending authority approves it, and it stays in the loan file for the life of the loan. It is the document loan review and examiners read when they want to know why the bank made a loan and how it rated the risk.
The term has a second meaning. In accounting, a credit memo is a note a seller issues to reduce what a customer owes, for example after a return; on a bank statement it can also mean a credit to your account. This page is about the lending meaning only.
Banks use different names for the same document: credit memorandum, credit approval memo, loan presentation, credit write-up or credit package. The content is broadly the same.
What goes in a credit memo
Formats vary by bank and loan size, but a commercial credit memo usually covers these sections:
- Request summary. Borrower, amount, purpose, rate, term, amortisation, collateral, guarantors and the recommendation, usually on the first page.
- Borrower background. The business, its history, ownership, management and industry, and the bank's existing relationship.
- Total exposure. All loans to the borrower and related parties, existing and proposed, measured against house and legal lending limits.
- Sources and uses. Where the funds come from and where they go, including the borrower's own equity.
- Financial analysis. A summary of the spread financial statements, with trends in revenue, margins, leverage and liquidity, and an explanation of what changed.
- Repayment capacity. Debt service coverage for the business and, for closely held companies, global cash flow combining the business and its guarantors.
- Collateral. What is pledged, how it was valued and when, loan-to-value and lien position.
- Guarantor analysis. The guarantors' personal financial position, liquidity, contingent liabilities and credit history.
- Risk rating, risks and mitigants. The proposed risk rating with its rationale, and the main risks with how each is mitigated.
- Policy exceptions. Any way the loan falls outside credit policy, with the justification.
- Covenants and conditions. Financial covenants, reporting requirements and conditions that must be met before closing or funding.
- Recommendation and approvals. The analyst's recommendation and the signatures required under the bank's loan policy.
Many of these sections draw on the five Cs of credit, which our guide to the loan underwriting process explains.
Who writes and who reads a credit memo
Writers. At most community banks a credit analyst or underwriter writes the memo, working with the relationship lender who knows the borrower. In smaller banks the lender may write it themselves.
Approvers. The memo goes to whoever holds the lending authority for that loan under the board-approved loan policy: an individual officer, a senior credit officer, a loan committee or the board. Approvers often send questions back before deciding.
Later readers. The memo keeps being read after approval. Loan officers use it for annual reviews. The bank's independent loan review function samples files to test whether ratings are accurate and analysis is sound, as described in the Interagency Guidance on Credit Risk Review Systems. Examiners read memos when they review the loan portfolio, and internal and external auditors may too.
Common weaknesses examiners and loan reviewers flag
Credit memos are judged on whether they support the decision and the risk rating. Weaknesses that come up often in loan review and exams include:
- Stale financial information. Analysis built on old statements, or missing interim figures for a borrower whose performance has changed.
- Weak cash flow analysis. Repayment capacity asserted rather than shown, or no global cash flow when the guarantors are the real support.
- Unsupported risk ratings. A rating that does not match the analysis, or that was not updated when performance changed.
- Policy exceptions not identified. Exceptions that are present but not listed, justified or approved at the right level.
- Collateral gaps. Out-of-date valuations, missing evaluations or LTV calculated on the wrong value.
- Thin guarantor analysis. No look at liquidity or contingent liabilities, so the guarantee's real value is unclear.
- Narrative that does not match the numbers. Boilerplate copied from the previous memo, or text that describes the business differently from the spread.
- Covenants not tracked. Covenants written into the approval but never set up for monitoring after closing.
Most of these are not failures of judgement. They are signs of a memo written under time pressure. Banks should confirm their own memo standards against their loan policy and examiner feedback; our guide to bank exam preparation covers the wider exam.
New loan memos and annual review memos
The memo written to approve a new loan is not the last one. Most banks require a periodic review of larger commercial relationships, typically when the borrower's annual financial statements arrive. The annual review memo updates the spread, retests repayment capacity and covenants, confirms or changes the risk rating and notes anything that has changed in the business, the collateral or the guarantors. Renewals and modifications need their own write-ups too. Across a commercial portfolio, review memos can add up to as much work as new loan memos, and they are often where stale information creeps in.
What makes a strong credit memo
- Lead with the answer. The request, the recommendation and the main risks should be clear from the first page.
- Show the numbers, then explain them. Ratios should come with their inputs, and the narrative should say why they moved.
- Name the primary and secondary sources of repayment. The approver should never have to infer them.
- List exceptions openly. An exception that is named and justified is a judgement call; one that is buried is a finding.
- Write for the next reader. Loan review and examiners will read the memo without the lender in the room.
How long a credit memo takes to write
It depends on the loan. A small renewal for a long-standing borrower may need only an update. A new commercial real estate loan with several guarantors can take an analyst much longer, because each set of statements has to be spread and reconciled before writing starts. Much of that time is spent collecting, keying and checking, not analysing.
How a community bank automates this
Lamatic builds agentic AI for community banks. A credit memo workflow on Lamatic runs like this:
- Inputs. The loan package from your loan origination system or document store: financial statements, tax returns, personal financial statements, rent rolls, appraisals and the term sheet, plus your credit policy and memo template.
- Spreading. The agent spreads the statements into your format and links each figure to its source page.
- Calculations. It calculates DSCR, global cash flow, leverage, liquidity and LTV using your bank's definitions, with the inputs shown.
- Policy check. It compares the request with your credit policy and lists each exception against the limit.
- Draft. It drafts every section of the memo, including the risk narrative and a proposed rating with reasons.
- Analyst review. The analyst checks the numbers, edits the narrative and signs. The approver decides. The agent never approves a loan.
The audit trail records the source documents, extracted figures, calculations, the agent's draft and every human edit and approval, which is the record loan review and examiners ask for. See AI-drafted credit memos for the full solution, or browse AI for community banks.
Frequently Asked Questions
In lending, a credit memo is the written analysis a bank prepares to recommend and approve a loan. It covers the borrower, the request, repayment capacity, collateral, risks, policy exceptions and the recommendation.
Not in lending. In accounting, a credit memo or credit note reduces what a customer owes. In commercial lending, a credit memo is the loan approval document.
Usually a credit analyst or underwriter, working with the relationship lender. It is approved by an officer or committee with the right lending authority.
It varies with the size and complexity of the loan. A small renewal may be a few pages, while a large commercial real estate loan with several guarantors is much longer.
Whether the analysis supports the decision and the risk rating: current financials, clear cash flow and global cash flow analysis, supported collateral values, identified policy exceptions and covenants that are tracked.
AI can draft one: spreading the financials, calculating ratios and writing a first version of each section. An analyst should review and sign it, and a person with lending authority makes the decision.
See a credit memo drafted on Lamatic
Book a demo to see an agent spread a loan package and draft a credit memo for your analyst to review and sign.
Book a Demo